/code-review ultra fails server-side and consumes free-review quota with zero output

Status Open
Maintainer reply None cached
Activity 0 comments · opened Aug 19, 2026

Description

Running /code-review ultra (the cloud multi-agent ultrareview) failed twice in a row on the same branch, both times with the orchestrator reporting that all review agents terminated before completing. No findings were produced either time, but both runs appear to have been counted against my free ultra-review allotment (3 free reviews granted, all 3 now show as used despite 0 successful reviews).

Steps to reproduce

  1. On a feature branch with a moderately large diff (~30 files, ~10k lines changed, mostly test fixtures), run /code-review ultra.
  2. Cloud review launches and returns a task-notification with task-type: remote_agent.
  3. After several minutes, task completes with status: failed.

Observed

Two separate cloud review invocations failed with the same error:

  • task id rs2zd03il — 2026-08-18T12:32:04Z — Cloud review failed: orchestrator reported an error: Review failed: all review agents terminated before completing
  • task id ryzh1rsds — 2026-08-18T12:44:31Z — same error, no findings produced

Neither run produced any findings or partial output. This looks like an infrastructure/resource issue in the cloud review orchestrator rather than anything about the diff content, since a subsequent local diff-size check (diff too large for ultrareview) on the same branch behaved correctly and didn't even attempt to launch.

Expected

  • The cloud review either succeeds, or fails clearly before consuming a billed/limited free-review credit.
  • Failed runs where zero agents completed and zero findings were returned should not count against the free-review quota (3 free ultra reviews), or should be automatically refunded.

Impact

All 3 free ultra reviews are now showing as consumed, despite never receiving a single successful review.

Environment

  • Claude Code CLI
  • Repo: local git repo (not run through GitHub PR flow — invoked as bare /code-review ultra on the current branch)

View original on GitHub ↗