Agent failure: Recorded a decision as settled without checking existing state first

Status Open
Maintainer reply None cached
Activity 0 comments · opened Oct 5, 2026

What happened: The agent logged blog-setup decisions ('use account X, create the publication') without first checking that the user had already created the publication a week earlier under another account. Corrected about 10 minutes later.

Impact on the user: A wrong decision record had to be voided and corrected.

Expected: complete, verified work on the first pass, without the user having to correct it.

Ask: please improve Claude / Claude Code so this failure mode stops recurring.

_Environment: Claude Code (Opus) on macOS, 2026-10-05. Filed at the user's request; one issue per failure that day._

View original on GitHub ↗