C:/Program Files/Git/voice transcription mistypes ~50% of words in noisy environments (street/store)
Summary
/voice (hold-to-record dictation, push-to-hold mode) mistypes roughly half of what I say when there is background noise. Words are not just dropped — they are confidently replaced with different, unrelated words. The output reads like a plausible sentence but is not what I said.
Environment
- OS: Windows 11 Home Single Language 10.0.26200
- Claude Code: Opus 4.7 (1M context)
- Voice mode: hold (Space-to-record)
- Dictation language: en
- Location at time of failure: near a road / inside a retail store (traffic + ambient store noise)
- Mic: built-in laptop mic (no headset)
Symptom
Held Space, spoke a sentence at normal volume, released. The transcription that appeared in the prompt was about 50% wrong — substituted words, not blanks. Examples of the kinds of substitutions I saw in this session:
- "rate" was transcribed as "read"
- "almost" came through as garbled noise that read as different English words
I was trying to fix an issue in code at the time, so the wrong words ended up in messages I was sending an AI assistant, which then acted on them.
Expected
In noisy conditions, I would rather see:
- a confidence indicator, or
- explicit \\[unclear\\] markers for low-confidence spans, or
- a higher rejection threshold so noisy audio returns "couldn't hear that, try again" rather than a confident wrong guess.
Repro
- Enable
/voice(hold mode) - Stand near traffic or inside a store with ambient noise
- Hold Space, speak a normal sentence
- Release
Result: a sentence appears in the prompt that is grammatically reasonable but ~50% different words from what was actually said.
Why it matters
When the dictated text is going into a coding agent that will then take actions (edit files, run commands, push branches), confidently-wrong transcription is significantly worse than no transcription. A mishear can cause the agent to do the wrong thing without the user noticing until after the action runs.
---
Filed on behalf of a user who hit this while working on a real fix in a noisy environment.
This issue has 1 comment on GitHub. Read the full discussion on GitHub ↗