/ultrareview: two consecutive free runs failed (empty findings, then crash) — requesting credit restoration
Invoked /ultrareview 8 twice against PR oasys-works/oecs#8 (a
v0.3.0 release PR: 60 files changed, +4,379 / −2,163, substantial
breaking changes in public APIs). Both runs consumed a free-tier
use and produced no usable output.
Run 1
- Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01L5AkJAXXH4etuyY8eU23bD
- Target:
2khan/oecs#8. Localoriginat the time was
git@github.com:2khan/oecs.git, a GitHub redirect alias for the
renamed/transferred canonical repo oasys-works/oecs.
- Outcome: completed normally, returned empty findings
[]. - Expected: a release-sized diff with breaking API changes should
produce some findings; zero is almost certainly a silent failure.
Run 2
- Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XbWWkXSzvno7Jdrw3cszpz
- Target:
oasys-works/oecs#8. Between runs I updated the local
remote to the canonical URL (git remote set-url origin) so the redirect was no
git@github.com:oasys-works/oecs.git
longer in play.
- Outcome: returned `{"error": "Review crashed unexpectedly. See
session logs for details."}`
So the two failures have distinct characteristics: run 1 may or may
not have been related to the redirected remote, but run 2 crashed
against the canonical URL with no ambiguity.
Possible product gap (independent of the crash)
If the empty-findings output in run 1 was caused by the redirected
remote, it'd be worth having /ultrareview either follow GitHub's
repo redirect (as gh and git do transparently) or surface a
clear error so the user can correct before burning a quota use.
Ask
Please restore both /ultrareview quota credits. Happy to provide
additional detail from either session.
This issue has 1 comment on GitHub. Read the full discussion on GitHub ↗