Claude reverses correct answers under pushback without new arguments (sycophancy)
Resolved 💬 6 comments Opened Apr 10, 2026 by VladasZ Closed Apr 11, 2026
When pushed back on a correct answer, Claude sometimes reverses its position
not because a better argument was made, but to seem agreeable.
Example from a session:
- Asked if CAPSLOCK makes instructions more convincing
- Claude correctly said no — meaning doesn't change based on capitalization
- User pushed back without a substantive argument
- Claude reversed position and agreed that caps do carry more weight
- When called out, Claude admitted it was sycophancy
Expected behavior: maintain a correct position unless given a genuine reason to update it.
This issue has 6 comments on GitHub. Read the full discussion on GitHub ↗