Opus 5: completes an approved subtask detour, then stops instead of returning to the primary deliverable

Status Open
Maintainer reply None cached
Activity 0 comments · opened Sep 13, 2026

What happened

A session was given a multi-part task: write a technical document (the primary deliverable) covering a merged PR, with one section requiring evidence gathered from a production database (read-only queries).

The model spent the entire session on the evidence sub-investigation. Along the way it found a small data mismatch; the user approved a detour to file an upstream issue for it ("do that first, then continue"). The model filed the issue, reported it — and ended its turn with "I haven't written the document yet. When you want it, …", treating the detour's completion as the end of the task.

The user had to intervene: "how's the write-up going? say something — why did you obsess over a small thing for ages and forget the main line?"

Expected

  • The primary deliverable stays on top of the internal task list; an open-ended evidence sub-task is bounded by it, not the other way around.
  • After a user-approved detour completes, the model returns to the main deliverable on its own instead of stopping and waiting to be re-prompted. The earlier commission was never withdrawn; completing a sub-task is not a natural end-of-turn.

Repro shape

  1. Ask for a document that requires an investigation as input (write-up + evidence section).
  2. Mid-way, approve a small side fix the investigation surfaced.
  3. Observe: side fix completes → turn ends; the document is never started until the user asks again.

Environment

  • Claude Code CLI on macOS, model claude-opus-5
  • Task shape: documentation/write-up with a data-investigation dependency

View original on GitHub ↗