[FEATURE] Bound background Bash tasks: optional deadline + surface output staleness in the Background tasks panel
Status Open
Maintainer reply None cached
Activity 0 comments · opened Sep 10, 2026
What happened
In a Claude Desktop (Code tab) session I dispatched two background bash watchers while waiting on a Cloudflare Workers deploy:
until [ "$(curl -sS -o /dev/null -w '%{http_code}' <asset-url>)" = "200" ]; do sleep 15; done— exited correctly after ~3 minutes.until [ "$(gh api .../check-runs --jq '<count of completed check runs>')" -ge 2 ]; do sleep 15; done— the assumption behind-ge 2was wrong. The provider (Cloudflare Workers Builds) updates the existing check run instead of creating a second one for the second push, so that commit only ever had 1 check run and the condition could never become true.
Watcher 2 spun for 24 minutes, polling the GitHub API every 15s, until the user noticed the persistent 1 running task chip and asked what it was. The deploy had finished long before, and I had already verified it through watcher 1 — the task was pure garbage by then. TaskStop killed it instantly once I actually looked.
The stuck loop is my bug, not the harness's — an agent-written wait condition that can never be satisfied. That is precisely why I think the harness should bound it.
Why this is worth fixing
- The Background tasks panel shows elapsed time but not output staleness. A no-op poll loop looks identical to a long build: both are just "Bash 24m 06s".
Monitorhastimeout_ms(default 300000, max 3600000).Bashwithrun_in_background: truehas no equivalent — thetimeoutparameter documents itself as the foreground command timeout. So the dispatch path most likely to carry an agent-writtenuntilloop is the one path with no deadline at all.- The user's first reading was "this is a Claude Desktop bug, I've seen this before". A silently spinning task costs trust in the panel's state even when the app is behaving correctly.
Ask
- Let
Bashwithrun_in_background: trueaccept a deadline (same shape asMonitor.timeout_ms) with a sane default, and mark the task timed out rather than leaving itRunningforever. - In the Background tasks panel, show last-output age (e.g.
no output 12m) so a no-op loop is visible at a glance. - Optional: warn at dispatch when a backgrounded command is an
until/whilepoll loop with no deadline.
Related
- #55893 (closed as not planned) — same failure family (polling loops that never exit), but focused on cross-session orphans and
TaskStopnot reaching prior-session IDs. This ask is narrower: a deadline plus visible staleness for tasks in the current session. - #74219 — nested subagents stuck as
Runningin the same panel.
Environment
- Claude Desktop, Code tab
- Opus 5
- macOS, darwin 25.6.0