Auto-compact should trigger earlier / threshold should be configurable
Resolved 💬 8 comments Opened Feb 25, 2026 by royleon55 Closed Apr 15, 2026
Problem
When autoCompact is enabled, the auto-compact trigger threshold is too close to the hard context window limit. This creates a failure scenario where:
- Context grows rapidly (e.g., large file reads, verbose tool outputs) and overshoots past the auto-compact threshold straight to the hard limit
- Claude stops working and advises running
/compactmanually - Manual
/compactthen fails with "conversation is too long" — because the conversation is so large that even the compaction request can't fit in the context window - The only option left is
/clear, which destroys all conversation context
This is a catch-22: auto-compact didn't trigger when it should have, and manual compact can't rescue the situation.
Proposed Solution
- Make the auto-compact threshold configurable — allow users to set a percentage (e.g., trigger at 80% or 85% of the context limit instead of the current default)
- Trigger auto-compact earlier by default — even a 5% earlier threshold would provide enough buffer to avoid the failure scenario described above
- Ensure
/compactalways works — if the conversation is too long to compact normally, consider a more aggressive fallback (e.g., truncating older messages before compacting)
Example config:
{
"autoCompact": true,
"autoCompactThreshold": 0.85
}
Impact
This is a significant UX issue. Losing an entire long session's context because auto-compact failed silently and manual compact can't recover is extremely frustrating — especially during complex multi-file tasks where rebuilding context is costly.
Environment
- Claude Code CLI
autoCompact: truein settings- Model: Claude Opus
- Platform: macOS
This issue has 8 comments on GitHub. Read the full discussion on GitHub ↗